
When i first saw teaser and concept images for this version of John Carter i was weary at best. Disney has reliable track record of making things like this well, but never glorious or epic. They rely heavily on CG and old school Kung Fu movie wire work, which was also kind of a red flag becuase movies like this often turn out looking a little dull and a lot hard to buy into. Logically since I was so excited that a classic sci-fi novel over a hundred years old was finally getting it's shot at a movie, i read the first book that this movie is loosely based on ; A Princess of Mars. And let me tell you two things right off the bat, that book is amazing and R rated. It plays out differently from the PG-13 adaptation i saw on screen.
But it still turned out as an epic sci-fi adventure.
So let's give a brief run of the plot and some of the changed made from the book; an ex solider in a post civil war america is completely down on his luck and spends half his time avoiding the law and half his time searching for a legendary cave of gold that no one believes exists. So of course whilst one day avoiding said law he stumbles into said magical cave. Sadly when someone appears out of no where Carter gets startled, which is normal when someone appears out of nowhere, and shoots him. Turns out he some sorta alien guy and his dying breathes send Carter through a portal to Barsoom, also known as Mars and is dropped into a war between two different factions of humans humanoid martians as immediately sides with the pretty girl and her scientific people who are being oppressed. Now it's worth noting that the main alien looking species are the Tharks, who are tall and green with four arms, who want nothing to do with this war but occasionally get dragged in when the fighting hits to close to their cities. They have a much bigger role in the book with their own internal conflict but the movie can only be so long.
That's basically it, since John Carter is from earth his physiology (Sciencey stuff I know) makes him able to jump great distances and gives him effective super strength becuase the gravity is so lessened. Which is really cool, they end up using a lot of very practical effects to make him and his jumping very real and really adds to the cool factor. If they had green screened all his jumps it would've ruined the movie.
The movie ends up working, but not without a few bumps; As far as heroes go John Carter is as bland as they come with no long term motivation for anything, but the movie insisted on wasting a solid fifteen minutes of an already two and a half hour long movie crow baring in a terrible back story about his family dying while he was fighting in the war. It's out of place ans useless but it doesn't linger through the second half. I guess to make it a blockbuster writers also jammed in villainous characters from later books that are like guardian gods of making sure everything happens how it's supposed to. Like in the Adjustment Bureau, but while that was the whole plot of that movie, they aren't really apart of the book and i feel like they could have made the main villain better if they had focused less on trying to have both, even though both characters are acted superbly. The fact of the matter is all the acting is great, even the voices and faces of the CGI Tharks who look as good as the blue creatures from Avatar, except more interesting. The real stand out in the cast is Lynn Collins as the Princess Dejah Thoris, who is the best character in the book, so it makes sense that she'd have the strongest on screen presence. Taylor Kitsch isn't bad as John Carter, in fact he fits the character quiet well. But i didn't always buy into him being as selfish as he was supposed to be. IN the first half of the story he doesn't want anything to do with the conflict he just wants to get home but i never really see that on Kitsch's face.
These however are all little complaints, the movie is a sci-fi epic like few others and i hope they continue the series into the later books. It has an interesting twist that clearly leads into more stories so why couldn't they?
It gets an A- from me, definitely go and see it and love it.